Jump to content




Breaking Coil springs


  • Please log in to reply
3 replies to this topic

#1 deo1mon

deo1mon

    Little Megger

  • Members
  • 84 posts
  • Location:, , ,

Posted 04 February 2012 - 05:12 PM

Having had my Ford Mondeo now for some time there is something i would like to share with those out there who may encounter this problem of coil spring breakages and why it happens? It seems to be that from the expensive to the cheap there does not seem to be a reliable coil spring which will last a good few years. I would also like to tell anyone of just replacing the whole unit with one from a scrap yard rather then getting the spring replaced to avoid this. I have done it when i just could not be bothered to replace the coil spring. The problem with buying second hand struts is that you don't really know what sort of mileage the car has done that the strut came from. In short really unless you are lucky enough to get a strut with a brand new spring it is false economy to go down that route. Ok if you have a leaky strut or one with no damping effect then maybe ok, but still replace the spring before fitting. So just go out and buy a brand new spring.

Obviously roads that have these sleeping Policeman fitted do not help any suspension especially if you are the sort who drives over these ramps to the point of take off rather than taking them gently. But these alone will not break any coil spring unless the coil spring has been severly weakened during manufacture.
Normally what happens is the paint these springs are thinly coated with breaks open allowing water to collect around that area of the spring causing the metal to oxidise thus then eats away at the metal of the spring and causing it to have a severe weak point. Now if you have a spring which is rotten in a certain part of it that is where it is going to finally break! Now i have gone from most expensive to the cheap on Ebay and it does not really matter what price you pay for the spring as they all break and really just because its the most expensive does not mean to say its going to last longer than a cheapy coil spring. But when i say cheapy i know there are some dire makes out there, but there are coil springs which come out around say £26 including postage and delivery that are just as good as the most expensive. The only difference you may have is that the warranty on an expensive spring maybe longer, but it does not mean to say its been made any better.

It will always be mostly the fronts will break more than the rears but that is not to say they never break on the back because they do!
Also if you are fitting a coil spring for the first time make sure that you take a good look how the spring is located in the strut and at the top. Because if the new spring does not go into the stop point mostly on the top plate the car is an MOT failure if the MOT inspector sees it which likely he will. Usually termed as Coil spring not correctly located. I will include some pictures.
Timing cover all in one
Uploaded 05 Jul 2011 - 22:27
Timing cover all in one
Uploaded 05 Jul 2011 - 22:27

Attached Thumbnails

  • spring one.jpg
  • strut 2.jpg
  • broken spring.jpg


#2 sgking

sgking

    ST200 Limited Ghia X

  • Members
  • 5,287 posts
  • Vehicle Driven:car
  • Location:Qatar

Posted 05 February 2012 - 12:01 PM

interesting post! i will have to check mine are still located correctly.

to add to your observations, the fail rate of springs seems to only be relevant to ford springs or aftermarket copy's. Uprated springs from Koni, Spax., Eibach etc dont snap, or at least ive never heared of anyone complaining of a snappage in the 10 years or so that ive been on here, compared to hundreds of complaints of snapped standard springs. :)
Mondeo 2000 ST24, st200 rear bumper & remus twins, st200 limited interior, extended marble theme, st200 suspension & airbox. trip computer, aws, fully undersealed

Mondeo ST200 Limited Edition no 181/300 'Ghia X' - Cruise Control, AWS, Electric Seat, VNR 9000 & Factory Fit Ford Phone, Mk3 Auto-Dip Mirror, Parking Sensors, IMRC LED, Extended Marble Theme, Contour Cupholder, Glovebox Torch, Asbo Brakes, Powerflow Twins, Shortshifter, 15" subs, RS arches, Morrettes, Police Roof Console

#3 jaysback

jaysback

    MK1 & MK3 Megger

  • Members
  • 776 posts
  • Vehicle Driven:Mondy mk1 4x4 si
  • Location:Wiltshire

Posted 05 February 2012 - 11:35 PM

My 4x4 has a set from graham goode racing put on in 99, they are still going strong. Watch what happens now.... LOL.
As above, not heard of the decent lowering springs going but will have a good look next time mine is in the air and check they are still located correctly.
1996 Mondeo saloon 4x4 si, auralis (II) blue, Koni top adjustable shock, custom Graham Goode lowering springs 40mm F 20mm R, 16" 5 spoke alloys, Morimoto H1 mini projector with 50W 6000k HID converted headlights, racebits induction kit, needs a respray. Fast Ford featured July 98.
Diary here http://www.talkford....-mondeo-4x4-si/
2002 Mondeo mk3 2.0 tdci ghia x, panther black, factory xenon's, a few led's, 18" Team Dynamics Jet alloys & polly subframe.

#4 frembrit

frembrit

    MEG Corporal

  • Members
  • 1,351 posts
  • Vehicle Driven:ST24, W reg.
  • Location:Somerset

Posted 06 February 2012 - 06:14 PM

I might be one of the lucky few, as mine is still on the original springs at 113K miles, shocks were replaced about 3 years ago. Again, I've not heard of koni, Eibach etc breaking. (not that I can recall)
Mondeo ST24, 2000 W reg, Amparo Blue | ST170 Calipers and Discs | Goodridge Hoses | GW Decat | K&N Panel Filter | Black eyes | LPG
Honda Hornet, 2004, Matt Blue.




1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users